So, you just purchased your first whey protein, only to realize you must visit a toilet several times after consummation. It’s no surprise since whey protein contains fair amounts of lactose and alcohol sugars (the exact amount varies for each protein powder brand). While this is not the case for every person, since our allergies and intolerances vary, it might be yours.
Here we will discuss various types of protein and their effect on human digestion and absorption.
Table of Contents
A Tale of Two Proteins: Whey vs. Casein
In the land of protein powders, two giants reign supreme: whey and casein. Both are derived from milk, but they’re as different as night and day when it comes to digestion.
Whey: The Speedy Gonzales of Protein
Whey protein is like the Usain Bolt of the protein world—it’s absorbed fast. Your gut quickly breaks down this soluble protein and sends it off to your bloodstream, where it’s readily available to help rebuild those muscles you’ve been so diligently working on. This is one whey protein is one of the best choices as an after-workout supplement.
But beware, speed isn’t always a good thing. Some folks may find that whey protein causes digestive discomfort, bloating, or even the dreaded protein farts. Lovely, isn’t it?
Casein: The Slow and Steady Protein
Casein, on the other hand, is more like the tortoise in the race—it takes its sweet time. This slow-digesting protein forms a gel-like substance in your stomach, gradually releasing amino acids over several hours.
This makes casein a popular choice for a bedtime snack, providing your muscles with a steady supply of protein while you dream about your next PR. However, its slow digestion can also cause some bloating and discomfort for those with sensitive stomachs.
This is why casein is also not the best choice for right after-workout consumption.
Plant-Based Proteins: A Kinder, Gentler Option?
For those who prefer a more plant-based approach, proteins like soy, pea, and rice also offer their own unique digestion and absorption properties.
Soy Protein: The Middle Ground
Soy protein, the overachiever of the plant-based protein family, boasts a similar amino acid profile to whey and casein. It digests at a moderate pace, making it a nice middle ground between its speedy and sluggish milk-based cousins.
However, some individuals may experience digestive issues with soy protein due to its naturally occurring phytoestrogens and potential allergenic properties. So, if your gut isn’t feeling the soy love, it might be time to explore other options.
While there is still a huge debate about the soy-estrogenic relation, there are studies that confirmed that soy has an influence on human estrogenic and anti-estrogenic activity. While studies confirm that this activity is weaker than we originally thought, it’s still there. Whether that is important to you or not, I felt obligated to mention the facts.
Pea and Rice Proteins: The Dynamic Duo
Pea and rice proteins are like Batman and Robin—they’re better together. Individually, these plant-based proteins lack certain essential amino acids. But when combined, they form a complete protein with a balanced amino acid profile.
As for digestion, both pea and rice proteins are generally considered gentle on the stomach. However, their absorption rates can vary, so it’s important to listen to your body and find what works best for you.
Listening to Your Gut (Literally)
As you can see, each of these protein powders has a different composition and therefore, acts differently on a human stomach.
With that being said, each of us is different and one gut can absorb what others cannot. If this is your first time trying a protein powder and you have no problem with lactose, I’d suggest trying some whey first and notice how you will feel after consumption.
Personally, I had never any issues with whey protein and I actually like its flavor-based powders, so I’ll stick to it. But if it kept me bloated all the time (like it does my friend), I’d try a pea alternative. The soy would be my last choice, mainly because I don’t like the taste and there’s still (however weak) that estrogenic relation.
But you know what they say – you do you. I just provide the information folks, peace out.